Shop Around the Corner
1940 | Black and White | Not Rated | 1h 37m
1940 | Black and White | Not Rated | 1h 37m
In a little shop in Budapest, Christmas is approaching, romance is blossoming, and appearances are deceiving.
In a little shop in Budapest, Christmas is approaching, romance is blossoming, and appearances are deceiving.
In Ernst Lubitsch’s 1940 classic, Jimmy Stewart stars as Alfred Kralik: a shop clerk who unknowingly falls in love with his most irritating coworker through anonymous correspondence. If this sounds familiar, it inspired You’ve Got Mail, the later film with Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan. (Both are retellings of the play Parfumerie.)
The shop itself is almost a character of its own, filled with personalities, rivalries, and eventually a community of warmth and life. The employees make an amusing contrast: one flatters the owner, Mr. Matuschek (Frank Morgan), and agrees with everything he says, while another hides whenever he asks for honest feedback. Only Alfred is unafraid to speak plainly, even when he disagrees.
But despite Alfred’s loyalty, Mr. Matuschek comes to suspect him of having an affair with his wife. In his despair, he pushes away those closest to him, and nearly takes his own life. It is his lowliest employee who comes to the rescue, and the message is a very Catholic one: humility means recognizing that disagreement might be a form of love, and affirmation may be treacherous.
Meanwhile, Alfred is engaged in his own game of masks and misconceptions. He has been writing to an unknown woman, smitten by her ideas and shared interests. Likewise, Klara (Margaret Sullavan) has been writing to an unknown pen pal, in love with his eloquence, passion, and lofty ideals. At work they dislike each other, each insisting their mysterious correspondent is much better, without realizing that they have already fallen in love with each other's souls.
Both plotlines show how pride blinds us. Mr. Matuschek fails to see loyalty in an honest employee, and Alfred and Klara fail to see the beauty in the person standing before them. Each has expectations of what goodness ought to look like. Only humility lets them see what was there all along.
There is something wonderfully fitting about this story unfolding at Christmas. The world awaited a glorious Messiah, yet God arrived as a helpless infant in a stable. Those expecting grandeur could hardly recognize divinity in such humility. Perhaps we, too, must surrender our lofty expectations before we can recognize the beauty of what stands right before us.
The Shop Around the Corner is an annual favorite in our house. Parents should be aware of themes of infidelity and an off-screen suicide attempt, both handled discreetly, without graphic content or sensationalism, and neither overshadows the film's warmth and humor. The wit, romance, and heart will likely resonate most with teens and adults, but it’s a wonderful film to share with the family.