The Christmas Angels of Brooklyn
Dear Faith Reader,
As has been the case each year, the entries to the FAITH magazine Christmas Short Story Contest were outstanding. With several dozen entries, the task of selecting one winner proved difficult. In the end, “The Christmas Angels of Brooklyn” by Ann Mulligan of Saint Mary on the Lake parish in Manitou Beach was chosen for its good writing, heart, faith, and meaningful Christmas message. We hope you enjoy Ann’s story!
Mary Gates, Editor, FAITH Magazine
Dear Faith Reader,
As has been the case each year, the entries to the FAITH magazine Christmas Short Story Contest were outstanding. With several dozen entries, the task of selecting one winner proved difficult. In the end, “The Christmas Angels of Brooklyn” by Ann Mulligan of Saint Mary on the Lake parish in Manitou Beach was chosen for its good writing, heart, faith, and meaningful Christmas message. We hope you enjoy Ann’s story!
Mary Gates, Editor, FAITH Magazine
“Suddenly a great company of the heavenly host appeared with the angel, praising God and saying, Glory to God in the highest heaven, and on earth peace to those on whom His favor rests.” (Lk 2:13-14)
My mother, Gloria, was born on October 11, 1923. She was born at home, at 270 St. Johns Place, a brownstone apartment building in Brooklyn New York, which is where she spent her young childhood. We always enjoyed hearing the stories of her youth. Whether it was playing Potsy in the streets, (similar to Hopscotch), using rocks or bottlecaps as the markers, or just hanging on the stoop with her pals, her childhood seemed a wonder! Her favorite smell was the fresh bread at Ebington's bakery in Flatbush. Her favorite tastes were hot fudge sundaes and egg cream sodas, which contained no eggs and no cream, and perhaps only tasted so good because she loved sitting at the counter at Schrafft’s on the corner of Fulton and Smith. She enjoyed visiting the Brooklyn Museum and was fascinated by the Egyptian display, especially the mummies — which is still a grand feature at the museum today. At age 12 she and her friend Trudy were permitted to ride the subway to a neighboring borough to the home of Mr. Clyde Neff for piano lessons.
Her most cherished memories, as is true of many children, were all the Christmases she celebrated in Brooklyn. As a practicing Catholic family, Advent was taken seriously. There were no lights, or baubles, or evidence of wrapping paper at 270 St. Johns Place until Christmas morning. Though Gloria was an only child for years, she had a bounty of aunts and uncles scattered in various brownstones and apartments throughout the surrounding area, who would joyfully gather at St. Teresa of Avila Church for midnight Mass. As the last hymn played, it was off to bed to await the glorious morning.
It was difficult for my mom to sleep, the anticipation was so great. Apparently in the 1920s, St. Nicholas would drag in the fragrant pine tree, string the lights, and hang the bulbs on Christmas Eve after the little children went to bed. I can’t imagine how exhausted my grandmother — I mean, Mrs. Claus — must have been having to do everything at the last minute … including baking fresh cinnamon rolls, which ushered in the Savior's birth. It was always worth the wait.
When my mother was getting up in age, her late 80s, I asked her what her very first memory of faith was. Without hesitation she said, “As a young child, I remember just staring up at the high ceiling at St. Teresa’s and marveling at all the angels up there. I just knew God was real, and His angels are with us! Such a beautiful church. It is where I received all of my sacraments!”
Christmas was coming, and I realized the number of celebrations we would have together were now limited. I hoped to get her something really special that year. I had an inspiration. I decided I would like to capture the memory of her first encounter with faith and put it in a frame! Living in Michigan, I knew it would not be possible to go to Brooklyn in time for the holiday, so I researched photographers located close to the church. I found a young man in Brooklyn Heights who considered my request. “I’d like you to go to St. Teresa of Avila Catholic Church and photograph the ceiling. My elderly mother has such fond memories of the beauty of the angels painted on the ceiling. I would like to give her a framed image of it for Christmas. Would you be willing to do this for me?"
The young man seemed enthused! A Catholic himself, although a lapsed Catholic, he knew exactly where the church was, and promised to see what he could do. A few days later, he returned my call. In his very thick New York accent he regretted to inform me, “Well, I went ta da church, and dere were no angels up dere … so I roamed around a bit and ran into da good Fada, who was real cordial, and invited me to take a look at da church ah-kives. We went tru tons of pic-chas of the church back in the day. Turns out, there were neva pic-chas of angels up dere!! I took a photo of the church anyway, but you don't owe me nothin, cuz I had a nice chat wit the good Fada, and it was my pleashu to do it fo ya.” I insisted on paying, and hoped a picture of the church where she was baptized, made her first communion and confirmation would be a sweet gift anyway, even without the angels.
I presented her with the gift at our annual family Christmas party, and explained about the photographer, and the archives, and the fact that there were never angels on the ceiling. She cordially smiled as if to say “I know there were angels, but I’m not gonna argue on this blessed holiday.” The present did not land the way I had hoped.
Many Christmases have come and gone since my dear mother’s passing. One particularly cold Christmas Eve I felt especially lonesome for her company. I was sitting in the hushed church awaiting the first notes of the instrumental string music that always preceded the midnight Mass. I was thinking about the times my mother and I would get together and bake six or seven types of Christmas cookies all in one day. It was a marathon, and by the end we were always slap happy listening to Bing Crosby and Burl Ives as we baked. I recall the one batch we made that she added twice as much butter than the recipe called for and they ended up looking like lace pancakes. We named them "Gloria's foibles.” Mass began as the choir led us in singing “Angels We Have Heard On High.” It was hard to hold back the tears.
As Father began his homily, he spoke of the long journey Mary and Joseph had to make, and the lowly stable that was to be the bed for the King of the Universe. He spoke of the shepherds who witnessed a multitude of angels in the fields….” And do you know, that on this glorious night, and at every single Mass in every single Catholic Church in the whole world … there are multitudes of angels singing with us, not just on Christmas Eve, but at EVERY SINGLE MASS!!! If only we have faith to see and hearts to believe.”
Yes Father, I do believe, and I know of a small child in Brooklyn, New York, that never doubted.
Ann Mulligan is a parishioner of St. Mary on the Lake in Manitou Beach, Michigan. She is a wife, mother, grandmother, and a retired Catholic school teacher. Ann recently authored a nonfiction Catholic children’s book, The Belles of Lake Leelanau, published by Holy Heroes.